I have certainly heard my right hon.

That is what we have to the balance in considering this new tax, because we do not want to shut down the entrepreneurial spirit in many c

Normally I thank Opposition Members for their interventions, but that really was quite churlish.

I thank my right hon. Friend for his thoughtful intervention.

I thank my hon. Friend for that intervention, which gets to the point of the debate.

Yes, it is an interesting one.

It is a pleasure to speak in this debate, which is not the first I have ever taken part in on tax avoidance.

That is what absolute poverty measures.

If the Labour party is so committed to scrutiny of this Bill, how come the Opposition Benches are virtually empty? The hon.

This is about scrutiny.